Ankara Workshop on Financial Oversight
Forty-five officials and scholars participated in a CESS seminar held from 13-15 December 2010 at the Bilkent Hotel in Ankara. They discussed the oversight of defence expenditure by parliament and the Court of Accounts.
This event was the second in the programme Promoting Good Governance in the Security Sector of Turkey.
Forty-five officials and scholars participated in the CESS seminar on Financial Accountability and Budgetary Transparency of the Defence Sector.
Gathered at the Bilkent Hotel in Ankara from 13 to 15 December 2010, they discussed the oversight of defence expenditure by parliament and the Court of Accounts. This event was the second in the programme Promoting Good Governance in the Security Sector of Turkey.
The meeting actually consisted of two seminars. The first was a high-level seminar on the morning of 13 December. Parliamentarians and academics raised a simple but important question was raised: why do we need an army? Politicians around the world should always ask themselves this fundamental question, because it affects the way they plan their defence and it has direct implications for the defence budget.
But whatever the level of spending, parliament will need to allocate resources carefully and then to monitor how they are used.
The seminar then dwelt on the Court of Accounts. Here the discussion centred on performance audits. These are objective assessments that measure the efficiency and effectiveness of government expenditures and relate them to the resources available.
In Turkey this is a problem because of the secretive nature of military expenditures. In practice, the Court of Accounts cannot audit military spending, even though it has the authority to do so.
The high-level seminar was followed by an interactive seminar for parliamentary staffers, employees of the Court of Accounts, officials from government departments, and researchers. This ran from the afternoon of 13 December until 15 December 2010.
The two main themes of financial control (the allocation of resources and the monitoring of their use) were also at the heart of the interactive seminar.
We conducted a role-play exercise in which a minister of defence bought expensive helicopters from a supplier who was a close friend. Then for one and a half years, he obstructed attempts by the Court of Accounts to investigate his spending on the aircraft. As it was played in Ankara, the game paid great attention to the friendship between the minister and the helicopter manufacturer but merely noted the minister’s obstruction of the Court of Accounts.
When it came to evaluation, the participants gave the course high marks for relevance and quality. They especially appreciated the fact that we focussed closely on practical governance issues in a clearly defined policy domain.
They said they had found the training sessions quite tough and technical at times, but not excessively so. Their main point of criticism was that they would have liked more time for discussion.
Eight participants of the first seminar in CESS’s Turkey programme, held in October 2010, hadsubmitted an analytic policy memo for discussion. These memos were reviewed in a paper workshop held at the Bilkent Hotel in Ankara on 12 December. A panel of five experts commented on the memos, and this was followed by lively discussion. CESS will select the two most interesting papers and include them in a Greenwood Paper, to be published towards the end of the Turkey programme.
New Programme CESS in Macedonia
Wrapping-Up the Georgia Parliamentary Programme
Capacity Building Programme for the Georgian Defence and Security Committee
National Security and Human Rights Conference Serbia
Winter Course 2013, Ankara: Challenges in Security
In Memoriam: Vasili Tchkoidze
Concluding Conference: Good Governance of the Security Sector in Turkey
Study Visit Turkish Delegation to The Hague
Tailor-made training for the Indonesia Defence University
Civil-Military Relations Looked at from Different Angles
Rule of Law in Depth
Defence Budget Oversight on Agenda in Ankara
Moldovans and Transnistrians Training Together
Expert Report Presented in Georgian Parliament
Georgia Parliamentary Programme finalized
Croania Group on Facebook
Deputy Minister at Ankara Seminar
Baptism of Fire on Lake Bazaleti
Building Local Training Capacity in Georgia
Belgrade Exercise on Peace Operations
The Rule of Law and the Security Sector
Border Management Training in Dushanbe
Georgian Parliamentary Delegation Visits the Netherlands
Peter Volten Retired
Ankara Workshop on Financial Oversight
Mountaintop Workshop: “Communication is Key!”
It’s Not Enough to Feed the Cat - Training for Staffers in Georgia
Moldovan minister praises Chişinău workshop
UNDP Training Programme in Moldova Kicks Off
Georgian MPs Discuss Oversight of Military Operations
Lively Training of SSR Trainers at RACVIAC
Successful Pilot Courses in Kyrgyzstan
SSR Advanced Course in Croatia well received
CESS presents unique publication on SSR in Moldova
MP's discuss implementation of security reform in Tbilisi
Academia Meets Government and Parliament in Turkey
Harmonie Paper Launched in Istanbul
Lively Discussions at SSR Conference in Almaty
New SSR Training Programme in Croatia starts November 2009
German Training on Interagency Co-operation
Eijsink, Lagendijk join CESS Board
Conference on Security Sector Reform in Central Asia
Remembering David Greenwood
CESS video on Security Sector Reform Training
Training for European SSR Missions
Democratic Governance Training in Kazakhstan
Moldovan Parliamentarians visit The Hague
From Groningen to Belgrade: A Winter Course
Foreign Ministry in The Hague Hosts STARLINK Conference
Conference on Peace Support Operations
Conference on Democratic Governance in the Security Sector
SSR and Governance: Training at European Commission
From Rebel to Taxpayer? Working Together for Successful DDR
Transitional Justice and DDR
Disposing of Surplus Small Arms
First Starlink Course in Armenia: Setting a high standard
Bringing Azeri Government and Civil Society Together
Starlink Training Course 'Law Enforcement': Full speed ahead
CESS-SDA Content Partnership
New CESS Book on Civil-Military Relations in Turkey
International Syndicate for Training on DDR Established
Moldovan Ministry Officials Praise Starlink Course
Security and Stability in the Black Sea Area
First Starlink Training Course in Kiev a Success
www.cess.org: New Style, No Frills
DRINA Programme Continued
Occasionals: A New Series of Publications
Parliamentarians Meet in Ankara
Starlink: Partners Discuss Training Programmes
Study visit Turkish Delegation to The Hague